[Jump to content]

Building Societies Association

Member's Login

Join | Forgotten Password

Policy

Mutuality

Print page  |   Email 

Building societies and mutuality

All building societies are mutual institutions. Therefore people who have a savings account, or mortgage, are members and have certain rights to vote and receive information, as well as to attend and speak at meetings. Each member has one vote, regardless of how much money they have invested or borrowed or how many accounts they may have. This means building societies are solely focussed on delivering the best services and products to their members. This is in contrast to banks, who have a split loyalty between making a profit to deliver dividends to shareholders and delivering value for their customers.  The total management expenses of converted institutions are usually about 35% more than they otherwise would be once dividend payments to shareholders are taken into account.

During the 1990s a number of building societies demutualised to become banks. The All Party Parliamentary Group for Building Societies and Financial Mutuals has been critical of that process, publishing a report on the subject in March 2006.  The report and the BSA's evidence, can be found below.

BSA written evidence to the APPG enquiry into the True Cost of Demutualisation

BSA oral evidence to the APPG enquiry into the True Cost of Demutualisation

Windfalls or Shortfalls? The True Cost of Demutualisation

Demutualised former building societies

Earlier in March 2004, it was announced that the Government was going to conduct an independent review, chaired by Paul Myners to look into the corporate governance of mutual life offices, but also examining other mutuals.

In July 2004, following the publication of the Myners consultation document, the APPG took a decision to carry out a short inquiry into the extent to which mutual businesses contribute to the economy and society.

Please find below links to the BSA's evidence to the Myners Review, the APPG Parliamentary hearing, and the full APPG report.

APPG for Building Societies and Financial Mutuals Short Enquiry

BSA oral evidence to the APPG Parliamentary Hearing - 26 October 2004

BSA written evidence to the Myners Review

Appendix to BSA written evidence to Myners Review

Key benefits of building societies 

The key benefits of building societies' mutual status are as follows

  • They do not pay dividends to shareholders, and accordingly are able to operate on narrower margins than plc banks.  This means that, overall, building societies offer lower mortgage rates and higher savings rates than their competitors.
  • They are more likely to maintain their branch networks than banks, as they can take into account non-financial factors when assessing whether to open or close branches.  Bank branch numbers have been reduced much more rapidly than building societies' in recent years.
  • They can take into account much longer term issues when determining corporate strategy than institutions constantly under pressure to deliver rising dividends and a rising share price.
  • They can influence, favourably, the pricing policy of their competitors.  For example, pressure from building societies has prevented banks charging for access to cash machines
  • The UK has a much stronger financial services environment through the diversity which building societies offer.  They are based all over the UK, rather than in the City of London, which is the home of most financial institutions, and this gives them a different perspective.
  • They are much closer to consumer needs and aspirations because of their ownership structure.  Building society staff know that when they serve a customer they are serving one of the owners of the business.  This ensures a completely different culture in building societies compared to institutions owned by shareholders.  This is reflected in the higher level of service for building society customers compared to bank customers.

Follow the BSA on Twitter

Quick links for consumers

Find your lost building society account

Latest news

Lending and savings up at mutuals in 2011
31.01.2012

Mortgage lending by mutuals grows by almost a quarter in November
03.01.2012

BSA responds to statement by the Chancellor on the ICB
19.12.2011

BSA comment on the mortgage regulation proposals
19.12.2011

Seminars and Workshops

Conduct of Business and Compliance Seminar - click for details

Newsbite

Property sales slump – is there any good news?

January 2012

BSA responds on Government's ICB thinking

December 2011

Government publishes housing strategy

November 2011

The ICB recommendations: shifting boundaries

October 2011

BSA at Party Conferences 2011

September 2011

‘Building societies remain resilient despite challenging market’ - KPMG

August 2011

Newsbite archive

Mortgage Matters

Working Together puts Pressure on would-be Fraudsters

October 2011

Code Breaking in Europe

July 2011

The Proposed EU Directive on Credit Agreements Relating to Residential Property – A Bad Deal for Consumers?

May 2011

First Time Buyers Summit - Time for Innovation

February 2011

2011, the year the regulator listened?

December 2010

Mortgage Matters archive