Economists debate the role of firms in society – but can mutuals fill the middle ground?

Mutual businesses can incorporate broader factors, including social objectives, into strategies and decision making.

Andrew Gall, BSAWhat is the role of business in society, and where must governments step in to protect consumers, employees and communities?

A recent survey of prominent economists asked for views on this question.

The group, which included economists and former central bankers from the UK and Europe, was asked how much they agreed with a statement which summarised what is sometimes called enlightened shareholder value.

This is a slightly broader remit than that envisaged by the purist view that maximising shareholder value is the only goal needed for organisations. The statement was:

It is best for society if the management of publicly traded corporations only considers the impact of their decisions on customers, employees, and community members to the extent that these effects feedback to affect shareholder wealth.

18% of the economists agreed that it was best if managers of publicly traded companies considered the impact on stakeholders subject only on the effect on shareholder wealth. Based on the economists’ comments, this was from a theoretical view that giving managers too many differing objectives could risk giving too much managerial discretion, unless there were suitable accountability and incentive structures in place.

45% disagreed with the statement. However, it was not because of some deep faith in businesses to solve society’s issues. Many of these respondents recognised that there are effects that fall on other stakeholder groups and are not incorporated in the firm’s pricing – so called externalities – which mean that corporations can’t be relied upon to sufficiently look after wider stakeholders. There are also more broad-minded shareholders who would value the companies they own contributing to social goals. And social norms will constrain what firms can do in any case.

Oliver Blanchard, formerly Chief Economist at the International Monetary Fund and now at Massachusetts Institute of Technology, opened up the debate on social media, saying "… the answers show how confused we, the economists, are on the topic. Nearly none of the answers deal with the central issue: … The relevant question is: should firms behave differently?”

If shareholders are not willing to trade off profits, if consumers are not willing to pay higher prices, if CEOs who try get fired, or the firms which behave better go bust, is the world a better place?”
 

 

Yet he considers that, "The room for firms to deviate from profit maximisation is limited,” so that if societal issues such as climate change are left to firms we are more likely to get words rather than action, greenwashing rather than actual progress. As such, the government is likely to have to use laws and regulation to bring about change in relation to societal objectives. Others agreed that the government must step in as corporations would not act to the extent needed. 

However, alternative forms of business may offer something of a middle ground.

Previous BSA research found that employees at mutual building societies were much less likely than bank employees to agree that profit maximisation was the main purpose of the organisation, and they also thought that wider groups of stakeholders received more of the value created by the business than was the case at shareholder owned banks. This research has since been replicated and extended for Danish cooperative banks.

In a new report the think tank Demos suggests cooperative and social enterprises demonstrate how purpose-driven organisations could boost the UK economy.

These pieces of research indicate that mutual ownership can give more scope for businesses to address societal issues, by bringing the interests of wider stakeholder groups into the organisation’s decision making.

Of course, this is not automatic, and relies on strong governance, clear strategic focus and implementation.

But examples abound in the mutual sector – innovations that focus on helping first time buyers afford house purchase, launching UK Savings Week to get people saving, a focus on lending on sustainable and energy efficient housing, keeping branches open and supporting communities - showing businesses can have a meaningful, positive social impact without being directed by government.

 

You may also be interested in...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Mortgages & Housing

Building society sector grows as two banks are mutualised

Building societies and mutual-owned banks remain the driving force in the mortgage market whilst continuing to offer competitive savings rates.

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Mortgages & Housing

Disappointment for first-time buyers as Bank Rate remains at 4.25%

BSA comments on the MPC's decision to hold the Bank Rate at 4.25%

BSA Card
  • BSA.Event Event
  • Financial Crime

Financial crime prevention seminar

This full-day event in Leeds provides BSA members with expert briefings on current key risk areas in financial crime to help them review and focus the...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Mortgages & Housing

BSA welcomes changes that help to level the playing field between building societies and banks

The Building Societies Act 1986 (Amendment Bill) successfully passed its legislative stages as part of wash up today.

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release

With a third of people relying on their savings to get by, UK Savings Week aims to help those who can get into a better savings habit

The inaugural UK Savings Week runs 26 September to 2 October 2022

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release

The beauty of simplicity in a complex world

Speaking on the first day of the Building Societies 2023 Annual Conference at the ACC in Liverpool, BSA Chief Executive, Robin Fieth, talked about the...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • People

Debbie Enever to join the Building Societies Association as Head of External Affairs

Debbie will join the organisation on 1 September 2023. 

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Thought leadership

A partnership to put mutual and co-operative businesses at the centre of the new Government's plans for growth

Mutual trade bodies Co-operatives UK, The Association of Financial Mutuals, the Building Societies Association and ABCUL, have written to Sir Keir Sta...

BSA Card
  • BSA.Event Event
  • People

Women's Leadership Programme - "The Becoming Journey®"

Taking place between 12 Sept. - 3 Dec. 2025