Loading…

Guest blog: The future of member experience - What building society members expect in 2027

Following Sandstone Technology's recent webinar for BSA members, Ian Merlino, Head of Business Development, reflects on the future of member experience for UK building societies.

Ian Merlino, Sandstone TechnologyBy Ian Merlino, Head of Business Development, Sandstone Technology

The changing expectations of members

The financial services landscape continues to evolve at pace, shaped by digital innovation, changing consumer behaviours and rising expectations around convenience and service. Yet for building societies, the challenge is not simply keeping up with technology trends. It is understanding how to modernise while preserving the trust, community focus and personal relationships that have always defined the mutual sector.

These themes formed the basis of a recent webinar hosted by Sandstone Technology in partnership with the Building Societies Association (BSA), featuring insights from Annie Cossar, Chief Customer Officer at Market Harborough Building Society, and Alice Jackson, Digital Product Owner at Cumberland Building Society.

The discussion revealed a nuanced picture of member expectations in 2026, where digital excellence is increasingly expected, but human connection remains as important as ever.

Digital has become the baseline

Today's members are accustomed to seamless digital experiences in every aspect of their lives. Whether ordering from Amazon, booking transport through Uber or streaming content via Spotify, consumers have grown to expect intuitive, fast and personalised interactions.

As a result, those expectations increasingly carry over into financial services.

Members want to manage their finances conveniently, access information quickly and complete transactions with minimal effort. Digital services are no longer seen as a competitive advantage. They are an expected part of the overall experience.

However, while consumers compare financial institutions against the best digital experiences they encounter elsewhere, money remains fundamentally different from retail purchases. The stakes are higher, the decisions are more significant, and trust plays a much larger role.

As Annie Cossar observed during the discussion, members increasingly expect digital convenience alongside the reassurance that support is available whenever they need it.

The importance of choice

One of the strongest themes to emerge was the importance of channel choice.

Members are not asking for an entirely digital future. Instead, they want the flexibility to choose how and when they interact with their building society.

Routine transactions may increasingly happen online, through mobile apps or digital banking services. However, more complex situations often require personal conversations and expert guidance.

Mortgage applications, power of attorney arrangements, bereavement support and other significant financial events continue to drive demand for human interaction.

Building societies are uniquely positioned to provide both.

This hybrid model combines the efficiency of digital channels with the confidence that comes from speaking to a trusted adviser. For many members, particularly when making major life decisions, that reassurance remains invaluable.

Trust remains the defining factor

Throughout the discussion, trust consistently emerged as one of the most important differentiators for building societies.

Even members who complete their journeys entirely online often seek validation and reassurance. Some still pick up the phone during or after a digital application process simply to confirm that there are real people behind the organisation and support available should they need it.

This desire for reassurance highlights an important truth about financial services: convenience matters, but confidence matters more.

Building societies have spent decades, and in some cases centuries, building trust within their communities. As digital channels continue to grow, maintaining that trust remains essential.

The role of AI: enhancing, not replacing

Artificial intelligence was another significant area of discussion.

While AI continues to dominate conversations across financial services, the consensus among panellists was notably pragmatic. Rather than viewing AI as a replacement for human interaction, participants saw it as a tool to support colleagues and improve operational efficiency.

Potential applications include:
  • Improving access to information for staff
  • Supporting customer service teams with faster responses
  • Streamlining internal processes
  • Enhancing fraud detection and monitoring
  • Improving workflow efficiency
Importantly, both panellists stressed that trust must remain at the centre of any AI strategy.

Members need confidence that decisions affecting their finances are being made responsibly and transparently. As a result, the initial focus for many organisations is likely to be internal use cases that improve colleague productivity while preserving the quality of member interactions.

The message was clear: AI should strengthen the member experience, not diminish it.

Why mutuality still matters

As digital capabilities become more widely available, differentiation becomes increasingly important.
The webinar explored how building societies can continue to stand apart in a market where consumers can easily switch providers and manage accounts across multiple institutions.

The answer may lie less in explaining mutual ownership structures and more in demonstrating the outcomes those structures create.

Community investment, local presence, personalised service, financial inclusion and long-term thinking remain central strengths of the mutual model.

Increasingly, these values resonate not only with members but also with employees. Building societies are finding that their social purpose and community impact help attract talent who want to work for organisations aligned with their personal values.

For younger generations in particular, purpose matters.

Rather than focusing solely on products and rates, many successful mutuals are highlighting how their profits are reinvested to benefit members and communities. This creates a compelling story that extends far beyond banking.

Looking ahead

The future of member experience is unlikely to be defined by a choice between digital and human service. Instead, success will come from effectively combining both.

Members expect frictionless digital journeys, but they also value trust, expertise and personal support. They want efficient self-service when appropriate and meaningful human interaction when it matters most.

For building societies, this presents a significant opportunity.

Their community roots, trusted brands, and member-first focus provide a strong foundation for the future. By embracing technology thoughtfully while preserving the principles that have always distinguished the sector, mutuals can continue to deliver experiences that genuinely meet member expectations.

As the discussion concluded, one theme stood above all others: the future of member experience is not about replacing people with technology. It is about using technology to strengthen the relationships that matter most.

That is where building societies remain uniquely positioned to succeed.

You can watch the full webinar here.


 

You may also be interested in...

BSA Card
  • BSA.Event Event
  • Financial Crime

Financial Crime Seminar

This full-day event in London provides BSA members with expert briefings on current key risk areas in financial crime to help them review and focus th...

BSA Card
  • BSA.Event Event
  • Mortgages & Housing

Planning for 2027: a mortgage journey workshop for lenders

A free webinar hosted by BSA Associate, Novus Strategy Lenders are planning for more new lending in 2027, with the same teams handling product tran...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Mortgages & Housing

Andrew Pakes MP calls on building societies and credit unions to work together to help deliver growth in every postcode

BSA welcomes the Government’s first Co-operatives and Mutuals Champion at his first public engagement in the role

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Savings

BSA responds to the ISA changes in the budget

Commenting on the Chancellor’s decision to retain the current Cash ISA limit, Sarah Harrison, Chief Executive of the Building Societies Association, s...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Thought leadership

BSA welcomes appointment of Andrew Pakes MP as Mutuals Champion

BSA welcomes opportunity to turn Government’s ambition into practical action The Building Societies Association (BSA) warmly welcomes the appointme...

  • BSA.IndustryResponse Industry Response
  • Savings

BSA 2026 Budget Submission

The BSA's 2026 Budget Submission calls for the Chancellor to pause the proposed cut to the Cash ISA subscription limit and associated changes to Stock...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Savings

Cash ISA Transfer Performance Q3 2026

Collectively, the industry can report that 87 per cent of cash ISA transfers were completed within this timeframe between 1 January 2026 and 30 Septem...

BSA Card
  • BSA.IndustryPublication Research & Reports
  • Savings

Understanding the reasons for and barriers to saving

Saving is a cornerstone of financial resilience, yet many UK households struggle to build even modest buffers.