Loading…

Guest blog: The mortgage reset is coming. What can UK lenders learn from the US?

With millions of UK mortgage borrowers expected to face higher payments as fixed rates end, Jay Groce, Business Consultant at Digilytics, draws on experience with US mortgage servicers to ask what lenders can do now, while arrears remain low.

Jay Groce, Business Consultant at DigilyticsBy Jay Groce, Digilytics

The view from across the Atlantic

As an American who works with US mortgage servicers (the firms that manage loans day to day for whoever owns them), I find the UK market reassuring and worrying in equal measure. Arrears are close to historic lows: UK Finance counted 77,940 homeowner mortgages in arrears in the second quarter of 2026, just 0.89% of the total. Yet the Bank of England expects a little over five million households to see their payments rise by the end of 2028. Average five-year fixed rates passed 6% in October, a three-year high, and in November Bank Rate rose to 4%, its first increase in more than three years.

The UK’s regulatory framework and existing approach to supporting borrowers are materially different from those in the US. But the US experience shows why lenders should use periods of lower arrears to test whether their people, processes and systems can respond consistently at scale. UK lenders also have an advantage that US servicers rarely had: they can see when large numbers of borrowers will reach the end of fixed-rate deals, and can use that foreknowledge to prepare.
 
A different kind of payment shock

Most US homeowners hold 30-year fixed-rate loans. When an American borrower falls behind, it usually starts with a life event: a lost job, an illness, a divorce. Those shocks are random and rarely seen coming.

In the UK, the payment change is scheduled into the two- and five-year fix. For a couple borrowing £360,000, the difference between refixing at 4.5% and at 7% is more than £500 a month, with no change in their jobs, health or spending. That is a vulnerability, but a predictable one.
 
Lesson one: reach out before the missed payment

After the financial crisis, US regulators concluded that servicers had engaged too late. Since 2014, federal rules have required servicers to attempt to speak with a borrower in arrears by the 36th day, and to send written information about their options by the 45th. They were set because practice had fallen so far short.

The UK starts from a different place. All regulated lenders are already expected to support customers who are in, or may be facing, financial difficulty, taking account of their individual circumstances. Building societies often go further in providing tailored support.

The US lesson is about timing. A borrower whose fixed rate ends in six months, and whose new payment will take a larger share of their income, can be contacted well before any payment is missed, while options such as a longer term or a different product are still open. The known reset date is an opportunity to make existing support earlier and more targeted, in line with the Consumer Duty.
 
Lesson two: consistency matters as much as generosity

The US Home Affordable Modification Program, launched in 2009, aimed to keep struggling borrowers in their homes by permanently changing their loan terms. The problem was delivery rather than design: a government watchdog found lost paperwork, miscalculated incomes and eligible homeowners being wrongly turned down.

The regulatory response focused on process. Servicers must now assign personnel to borrowers who fall behind and must properly evaluate a complete application before pressing ahead with repossession. A borrower’s experience depends as much on how help is delivered as on which options exist. Two members in identical circumstances should hear the same answer, whichever branch, phone line or colleague they reach.
 
Lesson three: build capacity before you need it

In March 2020, Congress gave borrowers with government-backed mortgages the right to up to 180 days of forbearance, extendable by a further 180. By mid-May, less than two months later, 4.7 million US homeowners, or 8.8% of all mortgages, were in forbearance plans.

Servicers with clear criteria, trained staff and scalable processes absorbed the surge. Those relying on manual effort and goodwill struggled, and their borrowers felt the difference.

The time to stress-test operations is when arrears are low, and for the UK that is now. Fixed-rate maturity profiles show when demand for support may increase, so lenders can test contact centre and specialist-team capacity, staff training, decision-making frameworks, documentation and quality assurance in advance.
 
Lesson four: every forbearance needs an exit

US pandemic forbearance is widely regarded as a success. Research from the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia found that by early 2022, around three-quarters of the 8.4 million borrowers who had entered forbearance were up to date with payments or had paid off their loans. A major reason was that the routes out, including repayment plans, deferrals (moving missed payments to the end of the loan) and permanent changes to loan terms, were defined in advance, so borrowers knew what would follow the pause.

The UK’s Mortgage Charter built on support that lenders were already providing. Its options include six months of interest-only payments or a term extension, which can be offered without a new affordability assessment. These options can be useful, but they are not one-size-fits-all, nor a substitute for tailored support where a borrower is in financial difficulty. Whether support involves a Charter flexibility or an individual forbearance arrangement, lenders should consider from the outset what will happen when the temporary measure ends.
 
The mutual advantage

Building societies start with strengths that many US servicers lacked. American borrowers often dealt with a servicer acting for the investor that owned the loan, whose rules limited the help on offer. Building societies typically hold and service their own mortgages, know their members and keep branches in the communities they serve.

Societies and other lenders are not waiting until support is needed. They already encourage early contact, maintain trained teams, offer tailored forbearance and treat repossession as a last resort. The US lesson is that good support must be delivered early, consistently and at scale. With fixed-rate maturity dates showing where pressure may arise, societies can use this period of low arrears to test and strengthen the arrangements already in place.
 
Sources (for editorial reference)
  1. UK Finance Q2 2026 arrears (Mortgage Solutions, 13 August 2026)
  2. Bank of England Financial Stability Report, July 2026 (press coverage)
  3. Average five-year fix hits 6% (ITV News, 5 October 2026)
  4. Bank Rate rises to 4% (Moneyfacts, 5 November 2026)
  5. Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.39: early intervention (CFPB)
  6. SIGTARP findings on HAMP (HousingWire)
  7. CARES Act forbearance, 15 U.S.C. 9056
  8. Black Knight: 4.7 million homeowners in forbearance (May 2020)
  9. Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia: Tracking Resolutions of Mortgage Forbearances (February 2022)
  10. Mortgage Charter commitments (Which?)
  11. FCA PS24/2: Strengthening protections for borrowers in financial difficulty

You may also be interested in...

  • BSA.IndustryResponse Industry Response
  • Audit & Taxation

BSA Response to Exposure Draft: Risk Mitigation Accounting - Proposed amendments to IFRS 9 and IFRS 7

The BSA and ALMA have responded to the IASB's consultation on proposals for a new Risk Mitigation Accounting model.

BSA Card
  • BSA.Event Event
  • Financial Crime

Financial Crime Seminar

This full-day event in London provides BSA members with expert briefings on current key risk areas in financial crime to help them review and focus th...

BSA Card
  • BSA.Event Event
  • Mortgages & Housing

Planning for 2027: a mortgage journey workshop for lenders

A free webinar hosted by BSA Associate, Novus Strategy Lenders are planning for more new lending in 2027, with the same teams handling product tran...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Mortgages & Housing

Andrew Pakes MP calls on building societies and credit unions to work together to help deliver growth in every postcode

BSA welcomes the Government’s first Co-operatives and Mutuals Champion at his first public engagement in the role

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Savings

BSA responds to the ISA changes in the budget

Commenting on the Chancellor’s decision to retain the current Cash ISA limit, Sarah Harrison, Chief Executive of the Building Societies Association, s...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Thought leadership

BSA welcomes appointment of Andrew Pakes MP as Mutuals Champion

BSA welcomes opportunity to turn Government’s ambition into practical action The Building Societies Association (BSA) warmly welcomes the appointme...

  • BSA.IndustryResponse Industry Response
  • Savings

BSA 2026 Budget Submission

The BSA's 2026 Budget Submission calls for the Chancellor to pause the proposed cut to the Cash ISA subscription limit and associated changes to Stock...

BSA Card
  • BSA.PressRelease Press Release
  • Savings

Cash ISA Transfer Performance Q3 2026

Collectively, the industry can report that 87 per cent of cash ISA transfers were completed within this timeframe between 1 January 2026 and 30 Septem...

BSA Card
  • BSA.IndustryPublication Research & Reports
  • Savings

Understanding the reasons for and barriers to saving

Saving is a cornerstone of financial resilience, yet many UK households struggle to build even modest buffers.